INQUIRY 002 · DATA + AI

Comparing Dry Dog Food Nutrition: What Does the Data Reveal?

An AI-assisted comparison of Inukshuk 26/16, Eukanuba Adult Medium Breed, and Purina Pro Plan Complete Essentials Chicken & Rice using published nutrient data and AAFCO adult maintenance standards.

German Shorthaired Pointer sitting beside a bowl of dry dog food and a laptop displaying nutritional comparisons of protein, fat, fiber, calories, and key nutrients, with dog food bags and research notes on a wooden table.

THE INQUIRY

Choosing the right dry dog food involves more than comparing the protein and fat percentages printed on the bag. Different manufacturers disclose different nutritional information, making direct comparisons surprisingly difficult.

This inquiry examines three adult dry dog foods: Inukshuk 26/16, Eukanuba Adult Medium Breed, and Purina Pro Plan Complete Essentials Shredded Blend Chicken & Rice.

Using publicly available nutritional information, manufacturer-provided data, and the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) Adult Maintenance nutrient profiles, I explore how these formulas compare in protein, fat, calcium, and phosphorus.

The investigation also considers a critical limitation: guaranteed analysis values, reported nutrient concentrations, and dry-matter nutritional standards are not always directly comparable.

The central question: What can the available nutritional data tell us about these three dog foods, and what remains unknown?

DATA INQUIRY / DOG NUTRITION

Dry Dog Food Nutrition & Price Comparison

All plotted nutrient values are on a dry-matter basis. Inukshuk and Eukanuba use manufacturer-reported concentrations (October 20 and October 19, 2026); Purina uses average dry-matter values from a nutritional information screenshot for the believed matching Chicken & Rice formula (exact match not independently confirmed). Original label guarantees are preserved separately. Fiber and total omega-3/omega-6 have no AAFCO concentration reference lines in this dataset. AAFCO thresholds and clinical recommendations are distinct; neither alone establishes complete nutritional adequacy.

Nutrient data coverage

Coverage of the 7 nutrients currently tracked in this comparison. This is not coverage of the complete AAFCO nutrient profile, and availability does not establish nutritional adequacy.

Reported nutrient valueGuaranteed-analysis boundData unavailable
Inukshuk 26/167 reported · 0 bounds · 0 unavailable
Eukanuba Adult Medium7 reported · 0 bounds · 0 unavailable
Purina Pro Plan7 reported · 0 bounds · 0 unavailable

Other AAFCO nutrients are not yet tracked here. Missing manufacturer values will be shown as “Data not available” when additional nutrients are added.

Additional manufacturer nutrition information

Inukshuk 26/16 — Inukshuk Pro customer support email, October 20, 2026 (dry-matter nutrient values)

Vitamin D3: 1,390 IU/kg (dry matter)

Metabolizable energy: 3,630 kcal/kg; 472 kcal/cup

Calcium-to-phosphorus ratio: 1.20:1

Other minerals (reported dry matter; see product source): Potassium 0.74 %; Chloride 0.94 %; Zinc 217.8 mg/kg; Copper 18.9 mg/kg; Selenium 1.2 mg/kg

Other vitamins (manufacturer-reported dry matter): Vitamin A 29,144 IU/kg; Vitamin E 120 IU/kg; Thiamine (B1) 14.2 mg/kg; Riboflavin (B2) 12.6 mg/kg; Pyridoxine (B6) 4.3 mg/kg

Manufacturer-provided AAFCO suitability statement: Suitable for all life stages including growth of large size dogs (70 lbs or more as an adult). This is a manufacturer statement, not an independent verification of nutrient adequacy.

Original label guarantees: protein 26% minimum (As-fed); fat 16% minimum (As-fed); calcium 1.3% maximum (As-fed); phosphorus 1.1% maximum (As-fed). These are retained separately from the new dry-matter measurements.

Eukanuba Adult Medium — Eukanuba customer support email, October 19, 2026

Vitamin D3: 1,086.96 IU/kg (basis not specified)

Metabolizable energy: 3,755 kcal/kg; 376 kcal/cup

Calcium-to-phosphorus ratio: 1.3:1

Ash: Manufacturer could not provide a value

Original label guarantees: protein 24.5% minimum (As-fed); fat 15% minimum (As-fed). These are retained separately from the new dry-matter measurements.

Purina Pro Plan — Nestlé Purina PetCare email, October 23, 2026, case 25349247. As-fed values converted to dry matter using 8.7% moisture. Calories: 369 kcal/cup. Legacy kcal/kg and supplemental minerals not verified by this email.

Vitamin D3: Data not available

Metabolizable energy: 4,038 kcal/kg; 369 kcal/cup

Calcium-to-phosphorus ratio: 1.32:1 (calculated from as-fed values)

Other minerals (reported dry matter; see product source): Potassium 0.8 %; Sodium 0.45 %; Chloride 0.81 %; Magnesium 0.14 %

Original label guarantees: protein 26% minimum (As-fed); fat 16% minimum (As-fed); calcium 1% minimum (As-fed); phosphorus 0.8% minimum (As-fed). These are retained separately from the new dry-matter measurements.

Eukanuba vitamin D3 cannot be compared against dry-matter AAFCO thresholds until its reporting basis is confirmed. Manufacturer-reported concentrations and suitability statements do not independently establish nutritional adequacy.

FoodDM comparisonInterpretationOriginal published valueMoisture max
Inukshuk 26/1628.89%Reported DM28.89% reported (Dry matter)10%
Eukanuba Adult Medium29.02%Reported DM29.02% reported (Dry matter)10%
Purina Pro Plan29.57%Reported DM29.57% reported (Dry matter)8.7%

METHODOLOGY / READING THE DATA

How to Interpret This Comparison

This comparison separates manufacturer-reported concentrations from guaranteed-analysis bounds. Neither the chart nor its coverage summary establishes that one food is nutritionally superior or that a food meets every AAFCO requirement.

1. Why compare nutrients on a dry-matter basis?

Dry-matter (DM) percentages exclude water so that foods with different moisture contents can be compared on a more consistent basis. A label's maximum moisture guarantee is not a measured moisture value, however, so it cannot be used to calculate an exact DM concentration from a guaranteed-analysis value.

2. Manufacturer-reported measurements

A manufacturer-reported DM concentration is displayed as reported, rather than estimated from a label guarantee. For example, Eukanuba supplied dry-matter nutrient concentrations in its October 19, 2026 response. These reported values are different kinds of evidence from the minimums and maximums printed on a product label.

3. Guaranteed-analysis bounds

A guaranteed minimum means the nutrient concentration is at least the stated as-fed percentage; it is not the food's exact concentration. With only a maximum moisture guarantee, that as-fed minimum also provides a conservative DM lower bound. An as-fed maximum can provide a conservative DM upper bound by dividing the stated maximum by (1 − maximum moisture fraction). The chart uses ≥ and ≤ to identify these bounds; it does not present them as measured values.

4. How to read AAFCO reference lines

Where available, the dashed lines show AAFCO adult-maintenance nutrient minimums or maximums from the reference dataset used in this inquiry. They are regulatory nutrient-profile reference thresholds, not ideal targets for every dog. A plotted bound near or across a line does not, by itself, establish whether the finished food meets the full AAFCO nutrient profile or is suitable for an individual dog.

5. Missing data and other limitations

Data unavailable means a comparable nutrient measurement or guarantee has not been documented in this inquiry; it does not mean the nutrient is absent from the food. The seven tracked nutrients are only a subset of a complete nutritional profile. Manufacturer measurements and label guarantees may differ in reporting basis, precision, and evidentiary meaning. Prices are retailer snapshots and may change.

TOOLS + DATA

How the investigation was built.

ChatGPTTypeScriptApache EChartsSanity CMS

AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles — Adult Maintenance — Reference nutrient minimums and maximums for adult dog maintenance, including protein, fat, calcium, phosphorus, and other essential nutrients. Dry-matter values are used as reference standards, not optimal nutritional targets.

Inukshuk 26/16 — Published Nutritional Analysis — Retailer-published guaranteed analysis for Inukshuk 26/16, including protein (26% minimum), fat (16% minimum), calcium (1.3% maximum), and phosphorus (1.1% maximum). Values are as-fed guarantees, not measured dry-matter concentrations.

Eukanuba Adult Medium Breed — Manufacturer Nutritional Information — Manufacturer-provided nutritional information from Eukanuba Consumer Care, January 17, 2026, case #09437680. Reported calcium: 1.21% as-fed and 1.31% dry matter. Reported phosphorus: 1.09% as-fed and 1.10% dry matter. Public guaranteed analysis lists protein at 24.5% minimum and fat at 15% minimum.

Purina Pro Plan Complete Essentials Chicken & Rice — Official Product Label — Official manufacturer product label, formulation A445523. Guaranteed analysis includes protein (26% minimum), fat (16% minimum), calcium (1.0% minimum), and phosphorus (0.8% minimum). Values are as-fed guarantees, not measured dry-matter concentrations. The label includes an AAFCO adult maintenance feeding-test statement.

HUMAN REVIEW

AI assistance and professional judgment.

AI assistance: ChatGPT assisted with structuring the research, organizing published nutritional data, identifying differences between guaranteed analysis values and reported nutrient concentrations, and developing the interactive data visualization using TypeScript and Apache ECharts. AI was also used to interpret AAFCO Adult Maintenance nutrient profiles, develop the comparison methodology, and document limitations in the available data. All nutritional figures were attributed to manufacturer communications, product labels, or published retailer information. AI-generated interpretations were treated as analytical assistance rather than independent verification of nutritional adequacy.

Human judgment: I selected the three dry dog foods based on their relevance to feeding my young adult Pudelpointer, Diedrick, and my preference for regular adult maintenance formulas rather than higher-calorie performance diets. I prioritized protein, fat, calcium, and phosphorus in the analysis, assigning each nutrient a proposed weight of 15%, with the remaining 40% reserved for other essential nutrients identified in the AAFCO Adult Maintenance profiles. I also determined that the available data were insufficient to produce a defensible overall nutritional ranking. Manufacturer-reported concentrations, guaranteed minimums, and guaranteed maximums cannot be treated as equivalent measurements. Missing nutrient disclosures were not interpreted as nutritional deficiencies. The resulting visualization is intended to support transparent comparisons and identify gaps in available information, not to establish which food is medically or nutritionally superior.

BEHIND THE INQUIRY

Limitations and reproducibility

**Data availability:** This analysis uses publicly available product labels, retailer-published nutritional information, and direct manufacturer correspondence. Complete nutrient profiles were not available for all three foods. **Measurement differences:** Guaranteed minimums, guaranteed maximums, and manufacturer-reported concentrations are different types of measurements. They cannot be interpreted as equivalent values. **Dry-matter comparison:** AAFCO Adult Maintenance nutrient profiles specify concentrations on a dry-matter basis. Some product values are published on an as-fed basis. These differences must be accounted for before drawing conclusions about compliance with individual nutrient thresholds. **AAFCO interpretation:** AAFCO minimum and maximum values are nutritional standards, not optimal targets. Exceeding a minimum does not automatically indicate superior nutrition. The absence of a published nutrient value does not establish a deficiency. **Ranking limitations:** Although the proposed analytical framework assigns 15% each to protein, fat, calcium, and phosphorus, and 40% to remaining essential nutrients, an overall weighted ranking has not been calculated because the available data are incomplete and inconsistently reported. **Reproducibility:** Sources and published nutrient figures are documented in this inquiry. The interactive visualization was developed using TypeScript and Apache ECharts. Results reflect the available information and may change if manufacturers provide updated formulations or more complete nutrient analyses. **Scope:** This is an exploratory nutritional data analysis, not a veterinary feeding recommendation or an independent laboratory assessment of the products.

Continue exploringBrowse all inquiries →